top of page

Are you hungry or is it a craving?

Jan 15, 2020
5 min read

Updated: Oct 6

Are You Hungry or Is It a Craving? How to Tell the Difference

Have you ever finished a meal, felt perfectly satisfied, and then found yourself looking for something sweet? Or maybe it's midafternoon, your energy is dropping, and suddenly you're thinking about chocolate, chips, or whatever happens to be in the pantry.


We've all been there.


But here's something I encourage my clients to think about: Are you actually hungry, or is your body asking for something else?


Understanding the difference between hunger and cravings can be incredibly helpful, especially if you're working on improving your blood sugar, managing your weight, or simply developing a healthier relationship with food.


And while sometimes a craving is just a craving, other times there's a little more going on beneath the surface.



Hunger vs. Cravings: What's the Difference?

True physical hunger usually develops gradually. You might notice your stomach growling, your energy beginning to dip, or simply a feeling that it's time to eat. When you're genuinely hungry, a variety of foods will generally sound appealing.

Cravings, on the other hand, tend to be more specific. You might not feel particularly hungry, but you really want something sweet, salty, or crunchy. And sometimes that feeling comes on pretty quickly.


One question I've always encouraged clients to ask themselves is, "Am I hungry enough to eat chicken and broccoli?"


It's a simple way to stop and think about what you're feeling. But I also want to point out that hunger isn't always that straightforward. You can be physically hungry and still crave something specific, especially if you've gone too long without eating or haven't fueled your body properly throughout the day.


The goal isn't to ignore hunger or convince yourself not to eat. It's to become more aware of what your body is telling you.


Your Blood Sugar May Be Playing a Role

This is something I talk about with clients all the time.

What you eat earlier in the day can have a significant impact on how you feel several hours later.

For example, if breakfast consists of coffee and a muffin, or you skip breakfast altogether and grab something quick for lunch, you may find yourself reaching for sugar later in the afternoon.


Meals that are low in protein and fiber, particularly those containing a lot of refined carbohydrates, can lead to a rapid rise in blood sugar followed by a drop. For some people, these fluctuations contribute to increased hunger, fatigue, irritability, and cravings. I've written more about why stabilizing your blood sugar is so important for your overall health.


And this is where protein, healthy fats, and fiber-rich carbohydrates become so important.

When you build meals around real, nutrient-dense foods, you're providing your body with the nutrients it needs to support more stable energy and help you feel satisfied between meals.

If you find yourself constantly reaching for something sweet, you may be caught in the sugar craving cycle, where your food choices, blood sugar, and appetite can influence one another.


This doesn't mean you should never feel hungry. Hunger is normal! But constantly feeling like you need something sweet to get through the afternoon is worth paying attention to.


Hormones, Stress, and Sleep Matter Too

There are several hormones involved in regulating hunger and fullness, including ghrelin, which helps stimulate hunger, and leptin, which plays a role in signaling that we've had enough to eat.

Insulin also plays an important role in how our bodies manage energy. In fact, persistent cravings, particularly when accompanied by fatigue after meals or difficulty managing weight, may be one of several signs of insulin resistance.


But it's not just about what we're eating.


Poor sleep and chronic stress can influence appetite, food choices, and cravings. If you've had a terrible night's sleep, you may notice you're hungrier the following day or that you're reaching for foods you wouldn't normally crave.


And for women navigating perimenopause and menopause, changes in estrogen, sleep quality, body composition, and insulin sensitivity can add another layer to the picture.


This is why I always encourage looking beyond calories and willpower. There may be physiological reasons you're feeling hungrier or experiencing more cravings than usual.


What Should You Do When a Craving Hits?

First, take a moment and check in with yourself.

When did you last eat? Did that meal contain enough protein? Have you been drinking water? Are you tired, stressed, bored, or simply looking for a little break?


Sometimes a glass of water, a walk outside, or stepping away from what you're doing for 10–20 minutes is enough to shift your attention, and the craving passes.


Other times, you may realize that you really are hungry. If you're hungry, eat!


Choose something that will actually nourish and satisfy you rather than grabbing a handful of crackers or something sweet that leaves you searching for more food 30 minutes later.


Sometimes making a few small changes to your daily routine can make a difference. I've shared nine ways to help manage food and sugar cravings, including eating balanced meals, prioritizing sleep, and managing stress.


And sometimes you might simply want a piece of chocolate after dinner. That's okay too. Not every craving needs to be analyzed or resisted.


The important thing is understanding the patterns and recognizing when your body might need better nourishment, more sleep, or a little less stress.


Learning to Trust Your Body Again

One of the things I love most about working with clients is watching what happens when they begin nourishing their bodies consistently.


They're eating enough protein, including healthy fats, choosing carbohydrates that work for them, and no longer going through the day running on caffeine and whatever happens to be convenient.

Protein is especially important because it helps support satiety, muscle maintenance, and metabolic health. If you're wondering why I emphasize protein so much, I've explained how protein supports metabolism and weight management.


And remember, eating less isn't always the answer. When someone has been restricting calories for too long, hunger can become more intense. I've written about what happens when you're in a calorie deficit for too long and why supporting your metabolism matters more than simply eating less.


Over time, many people notice that their energy becomes more consistent, they're satisfied longer after meals, and those constant cravings begin to settle down.


And that's really the goal. It's not about having more willpower. It's about understanding what your body needs and giving it the support to function the way it's supposed to.

If you're struggling with constant cravings, energy crashes, or feeling hungry shortly after eating, there may be more to the picture than simply what you're eating.


At What Is Health, I help clients look at the bigger picture, including nutrition, blood sugar regulation, hormones, sleep, and metabolic health, to better understand what's driving their symptoms.


Ready to get to the root of what's going on? Book a free 15-minute consultation and let's talk about how I can help.


And if you know someone who could benefit from this information, please feel free to pass it along!

Comments


Thanks for submitting!

What Is Health, LLC

978-835-1733

Essex, MA United States

  • facebook

©2019 by What Is Health. 

All rights reserved. Statements on this website have not been evaluated by the FDA and are not
intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. For medical concerns, please consult a qualified healthcare provider.

bottom of page